When a second opinion is worth considering
Multiple medication trials without adequate improvement. Diagnosis feels wrong or incomplete. Side effects are significant and not being addressed. You feel unheard or rushed at appointments. Considering a major treatment change (starting or stopping medication). Approaching a life change (pregnancy, retirement, major transition) that affects treatment. Complex situations where specialist expertise adds value.
How to arrange one
You can ask your current GP or psychiatrist for a referral for a second opinion — this is a routine request. You can also self-refer to a new GP for a fresh assessment. For a psychiatrist second opinion, a GP referral is needed for Medicare rebates. Some psychiatrists specialise in second-opinion consultations and are experienced in this role.
What to expect from the appointment
A thorough review of your history, current medication, current symptoms, and what has been tried. Often standardised questionnaires are used. The second-opinion prescriber may agree with the current plan (which is useful reassurance), suggest specific adjustments, or recommend a substantially different approach. You are not obligated to follow the second opinion — it is information.
What to flag to your prescriber
- Any resistance from your current prescriber to a second opinion request.
- Confusion after receiving conflicting advice — worth a follow-up conversation.
- Any concern about the quality of care that motivated the second opinion.
- Situations where a third opinion feels needed — usually indicates the diagnosis or approach requires more specialist input.
Related reading: Switching Prescribers: How to Change GPs or Psychiatrists and When to See a Psychiatrist Rather Than a GP.
Frequently asked questions
Do I need permission for a second opinion?
No. You have the right to seek another clinical opinion at any time.
Will Medicare cover a second opinion?
Yes, for GP and psychiatry appointments through standard Medicare items with appropriate referrals.
What if the second opinion contradicts my current prescriber?
Discuss with both prescribers. Second opinions often clarify decisions rather than complicating them.
Evidence and sources referenced
- NICE Guideline NG222 — Depression in adults: treatment and management (United Kingdom).
- Royal Australian and New Zealand College of Psychiatrists (RANZCP) — Clinical Practice Guidelines for Mood Disorders.
- NPS MedicineWise — patient and prescriber resources on antidepressants (Australia).
- Royal College of Psychiatrists — patient information on antidepressants.
- TGA and FDA — product information for SSRI and SNRI classes.
- Maudsley Prescribing Guidelines in Psychiatry.
Keep a calmer record of the first 90 days
If you want a calmer way to keep a short daily record across the first 90 days, Causiq is being built for exactly that. Join the waitlist at causiq.com.au.
Join the waitlist